Pumpkins are synonymous with autumn, but not all pumpkins are created equal. While the classic orange pumpkin is often the star of the show for Halloween and Thanksgiving, there are many other specialty varieties that offer unique colors, textures, and flavors. Whether you’re a chef looking to elevate your fall dishes or someone who enjoys decorating for the season, these pumpkins offer much more than just good looks. From the smooth, creamy texture of the Long Island Cheese pumpkin to the ghostly white skin of the Casper, these heirloom and specialty pumpkins are perfect for baking, roasting, and adding a rustic charm to your fall displays. Let’s dive into some of the most popular specialty pumpkins, each bringing something different to the table.
Long Island Cheese Pumpkin
The Long Island Cheese pumpkin is an heirloom variety prized for both its culinary versatility and aesthetic appeal. Named for its resemblance to a wheel of cheese, this medium-sized pumpkin has a pale, creamy beige color that sets it apart from the more common bright orange pumpkins. Its smooth, burnished skin is gently ribbed, making it a favorite for fall displays and table decorations.
Culinary-wise, the Long Island Cheese pumpkin shines as one of the top choices for pie making. Its flesh is dense and sweet, with a fine, smooth texture that makes it perfect for purees, soups, and, most notably, pumpkin pie. It has a slightly nutty and earthy flavor, enhancing both savory and sweet dishes. When roasted, the flesh becomes tender and can be easily mashed or blended into various recipes. For centuries, it has been a staple in American kitchens, especially on the East Coast, where it originates. Despite its decorative use, its true value lies in its taste, which provides a rich depth of flavor, particularly when used in baked goods.
In the garden, Long Island Cheese pumpkins are relatively easy to grow, requiring a long growing season to mature fully. They are typically harvested in late summer to early fall and can weigh between 6 and 10 pounds, making them manageable for home gardeners. This heirloom variety continues to gain popularity as more people seek out traditional, less commercialized pumpkin varieties with a history of exceptional flavor.
Fairytale Pumpkin
Also known as the Musquee de Provence, the Fairytale pumpkin stands out due to its distinct appearance and impressive size. Weighing up to 20 pounds, this pumpkin has a flattened, cheese-wheel shape with pronounced ribbing. Its coloring is one of its most striking features, with a deep orange hue often tinged with shades of green. Over time, the green fades to orange as the pumpkin matures, creating a beautiful color gradient that makes it a favorite for fall decorations and centerpieces.
The Fairytale pumpkin is highly prized in the kitchen for its sweet, moist flesh that makes it perfect for baking, roasting, and making soups. Its flavor is often described as delicate yet rich, with a hint of sweetness that complements both savory and sweet dishes. French chefs have long used this variety for its versatility, especially in traditional recipes like tarts, soups, and roasted vegetable dishes. The flesh is dense and holds its shape well when cooked, making it an excellent choice for hearty autumn meals.
In terms of cultivation, Fairytale pumpkins are a bit more challenging due to their size and weight. They require ample space to grow and plenty of sunlight. They also need a long growing season to reach full maturity, but the reward is well worth the effort. These pumpkins can last for several months in proper storage, making them an excellent addition to any homestead or fall display.
Jarrahdale Pumpkin
The Jarrahdale pumpkin is a visually striking variety known for its unusual color. It originated in New Zealand and is part of the broader blue pumpkin family. Its unique blue-grey skin, occasionally tinged with white, gives it a haunting beauty that makes it a popular choice for autumn décor. Smaller in size compared to other pumpkins, the Jarrahdale typically weighs between 6 to 10 pounds.
However, Jarrahdale pumpkins aren’t just for decoration. Beneath the attractive skin lies bright orange flesh that is dense, sweet, and ideal for cooking. It has a mild, slightly nutty flavor that works well in both sweet and savory dishes. Its fine-grained texture is particularly suited for baking pies, muffins, and bread, while its firm structure also holds up in stews and curries. Roasting is another popular preparation method, as the pumpkin caramelizes beautifully and adds depth to any meal.
Jarrahdale pumpkins are relatively easy to grow and, like many specialty varieties, require a long growing season. They thrive in warm climates and need plenty of sunlight. These pumpkins store exceptionally well due to their thick skins, allowing them to be kept for several months in a cool, dry place.
Cinderella Pumpkin
The Cinderella pumpkin, or Rouge Vif d’Etampes, is instantly recognizable by its round, squat shape and vibrant orange-red color. It is named after the pumpkin that the fairy godmother famously transformed into a carriage in the Cinderella fairy tale. This pumpkin has a flattened shape with deep ribbing, making it a perfect ornamental squash for autumn décor.
In the kitchen, the Cinderella pumpkin is equally beloved. It has sweet, velvety flesh that lends itself beautifully to pies, soups, and roasted dishes. Its flavor is rich and slightly nutty, making it a perfect choice for savory fall recipes. Many chefs use this variety in baking due to its smooth texture and excellent taste when pureed. Additionally, its natural sweetness makes it an excellent base for soups, and it pairs well with other fall vegetables such as squash and sweet potatoes.
Cinderella pumpkins can grow to be quite large, often weighing between 15 to 20 pounds. Like other heirloom varieties, they require a long growing season and plenty of space to sprawl. They are typically harvested in the fall and, with their thick skins, can be stored for several months. While these pumpkins are visually stunning enough to serve as decoration, their true appeal lies in their versatility and flavor in the kitchen.
Casper Pumpkin
The Casper pumpkin stands out among other varieties due to its ghostly white skin, giving it a distinctive appearance perfect for autumn decorations and Halloween themes. Named after the friendly ghost, its pale exterior contrasts strikingly with the vibrant orange flesh inside. The skin is smooth with gentle ribbing, making it a great choice for carving, while also offering excellent structural integrity for baking.
In the kitchen, Casper pumpkins are highly regarded for their sweet flavor, making them ideal for pies, soups, and other baked goods. The flesh is dense and moist, which contributes to its smooth texture when pureed. For pies, it delivers a naturally sweet flavor that requires little additional sugar, while its firm consistency makes it great for roasting and savory dishes as well. Beyond pies, Casper pumpkins can be used in casseroles, pasta fillings, or even desserts like pumpkin bread or muffins.
Growing Casper pumpkins is quite similar to other pumpkin varieties, requiring a warm growing season, plenty of sunlight, and ample space for their vines to spread. They typically weigh between 10 and 16 pounds, making them a manageable size for most home gardens. When stored in a cool, dry place, Casper pumpkins can last several months, adding a long-lasting decorative element to your home, even as they await their culinary use.
Marina Di Chioggia Pumpkin
The Marina Di Chioggia pumpkin is an Italian heirloom variety known for its distinctive, rugged appearance. Unlike the smooth-skinned pumpkins most people are familiar with, the Marina Di Chioggia is bumpy, warty, and turban-shaped, with a deep blue-green hue. Its unusual, almost alien-like appearance makes it a popular choice for decorative displays during the fall, adding a rustic, old-world charm to any setting.
This pumpkin is not just about looks, though. Its dense, sweet flesh is highly prized in Italian cuisine, where it is used in traditional dishes like gnocchi, soups, and risotto. The flavor is rich and nutty, with a sweetness that intensifies when roasted, making it perfect for both savory and sweet recipes. Marina Di Chioggia is also a great choice for baking, as its flesh becomes soft and buttery when cooked, ideal for making pies, tarts, and other desserts. The pumpkin’s low water content ensures that it holds up well in recipes without becoming too mushy or losing its flavor.
While it may look intimidating, growing Marina Di Chioggia pumpkins is relatively straightforward. They require a warm growing season and plenty of room to spread, as their vines can grow quite long. This variety typically weighs between 10 to 12 pounds and, like many winter squash varieties, has a thick skin that allows it to be stored for several months. Marina Di Chioggia pumpkins are a fantastic choice for both culinary exploration and decorative purposes.
Knucklehead Pumpkin
The Knucklehead pumpkin is a unique and eye-catching variety known for its warty, textured appearance. Its bright orange skin is covered in green and orange warts or blisters, giving it a truly gnarly look that is especially popular for Halloween and fall displays. Knucklehead pumpkins bring a sense of fun and whimsy to any setting, making them a favorite for carving into spooky jack-o’-lanterns or using as decorative pieces in the home or garden.
Though primarily used for decoration due to its striking appearance, the Knucklehead pumpkin is also edible. It has a dense, slightly sweet flesh that can be used in various culinary applications. While it might not be the first choice for pies due to its less delicate texture compared to other varieties, it works well for roasting, soups, and purees. The flavor is mild and earthy, making it a good base for more savory pumpkin dishes.
Knucklehead pumpkins are medium-sized, typically weighing between 12 to 16 pounds. They grow well in most climates, requiring plenty of space and sunlight to thrive. Harvested in the fall, these pumpkins can be stored for several months, offering both long-lasting decoration and a versatile ingredient for the kitchen. For those who love the odd and unusual, the Knucklehead pumpkin is the perfect addition to the fall season.
Turban Squash
The Turban Squash, also known as “Turk’s Turban,” is one of the most visually striking varieties of winter squash. Its shape is irregular and distinct, with a bulbous base and a cap-like top that resembles a turban, giving it its name. The skin is often multicolored, with shades of green, orange, and cream, adding to its visual appeal. It is often used as a centerpiece for autumn décor, bringing a rustic yet exotic charm to any setting.
In the kitchen, Turban squash offers a sweet, nutty flavor that makes it a versatile ingredient in both sweet and savory dishes. The flesh is dense and moist, making it perfect for soups, stews, and roasted vegetable medleys. It is also commonly used in pies and casseroles, where its natural sweetness shines. Roasting is one of the best ways to bring out its flavor, allowing the sugars in the flesh to caramelize and intensify. The flesh can also be scooped out and mashed, or used as a filling for ravioli or pasta dishes.
Turban squash grows best in warm climates and requires a long growing season to reach full maturity. These squash can be quite large, often weighing between 10 to 15 pounds, and their thick skins allow them to be stored for several months, making them a long-lasting addition to your kitchen or decorative arrangements. For those who appreciate a squash that’s both beautiful and functional, the Turban squash is a fantastic choice for the fall season.
As the fall season approaches, it’s the perfect time to explore these specialty pumpkins that not only bring visual charm but also pack a flavorful punch in the kitchen. Whether you’re decorating your home, preparing for a fall feast, or simply looking to try something new, these pumpkins offer a diverse array of options. From the blue-skinned Jarrahdale to the rich and sweet Cinderella, there’s a pumpkin for every purpose. Don’t settle for the ordinary—try one of these unique varieties in your next dish or display and experience the richness of autumn in a whole new way. Ready to elevate your fall experience? Pick up one of these specialty pumpkins today!
Stop into you local Platt Hill Nursery and see us!
